A Fast Answer Isn’t Always a Useful Answer: What Evidence Planning Teams Should Expect from AI

A Fast Answer Isn’t Always a Useful Answer: What Evidence Planning Teams Should Expect from AI

Arysana Team

Arysana Team

November 12, 2026

November 12, 2026

a string is attached to a blue object

AI can help evidence teams find information faster. But speed alone isn't the measure of success. The real value lies in producing outputs that are relevant, traceable, structured and ready to support the work that matters.

AI is creating new opportunities across the life sciences industry, from exploring scientific literature to identifying evidence gaps and supporting value communication.

For teams in HEOR, Medical Affairs and Market Access, these capabilities offer exciting possibilities. But there is an important distinction between getting an answer quickly and getting an answer that genuinely supports Evidence Planning.

An answer may sound convincing but lack strategic context. It may reference research without making the original source easy to verify. Or it may provide useful information in a format that requires significant additional work before it can be used.

So, what should teams look for when evaluating AI for Evidence Planning?

1. Does the AI have the right context?

1. Does the AI have the right context?

1. Does the AI have the right context?

The usefulness of an AI-generated answer depends on more than the question being asked. It also depends on the strategic context behind it.

Evidence Planning connects a product's development, value story, stakeholder needs and wider evidence strategy. A general-purpose answer may provide useful background, but it may not address the specific question a team needs to resolve.

Consistent prompts aligned with Evidence Planning workflows can help teams explore relevant questions more systematically, particularly when supported by the right evidence and context.

With Maia, teams use consistent prompts in just a click

2. Are teams working from the same evidence?

2. Are teams working from the same evidence?

2. Are teams working from the same evidence?

Evidence Planning brings together different functions, each contributing its own expertise and insights. When information is spread across disconnected documents, spreadsheets and systems, maintaining a shared understanding can become difficult.

AI can make evidence easier to explore, but its value is limited if the underlying information remains fragmented.

A shared evidence library gives teams a more consistent foundation, helping them work from the same source material and connect insights across activities such as evidence gap analysis, study planning and value communication.

Maia leverages a single source of truth for Evidence

3. Can you trace the answer back to the evidence?

3. Can you trace the answer back to the evidence?

3. Can you trace the answer back to the evidence?

Trust in AI requires more than a plausible response. Teams need to understand where information came from and how it supports the answer.

A reference list is a useful starting point, but effective verification may also require access to the original source and the specific passage supporting a statement.

This makes it easier for experts to assess relevance, check interpretation and apply their own judgement before relying on an AI-generated output.

Maia's answers allow full traceability with a blue box around the source passage

4. Are citations delivered in a usable format?

4. Are citations delivered in a usable format?

4. Are citations delivered in a usable format?

Finding relevant evidence is only part of the process. Teams also need to document it in ways that support review, collaboration and further work.

Incomplete or inconsistently formatted references can create additional manual effort. Properly formatted citations and clearly presented supporting evidence help reviewers navigate information and provide a stronger foundation for reports and other deliverables.

The aim is to make references part of a usable output, rather than another task left for the team to complete.

Maia generates fully lists formatted reference lists

5. Can AI turn evidence into structured outputs?

5. Can AI turn evidence into structured outputs?

5. Can AI turn evidence into structured outputs?

A narrative answer may be useful for initial exploration, but many Evidence Planning activities require more structured information, such as evidence summary tables and comparisons across studies.

Turning a question into a structured, referenced output can help teams move from information retrieval towards analysis. It can also make findings easier to compare, review and use when identifying evidence gaps or considering next steps.

The value of AI grows when information is organised for practical application, not simply presented as an answer.

With Maia, generate fully referenced tables with just a question

6. Can teams actually use the output in their workflow?

6. Can teams actually use the output in their workflow?

6. Can teams actually use the output in their workflow?

Even a relevant, well-referenced answer has limited practical value if it cannot easily be carried into the next stage of work.

Evidence Planning involves multiple stakeholders, reviews and deliverables. If teams must spend significant time copying, reformatting and reconstructing AI-generated content, some of the time saved at the start can be lost later.

Exportable outputs, such as Word reports with in-text citations and a reference section, can help bridge the gap between AI exploration and practical delivery.

Human oversight remains essential. Teams must be able to assess the quality, relevance and accuracy of outputs before relying on them.

In one click, Maia can export the answer to a Word report

Why AI designed for Evidence Planning matters

Why AI designed for Evidence Planning matters

Why AI designed for Evidence Planning matters

These questions highlight an important distinction: general-purpose AI capability is not the same as suitability for a specific workflow.

Evidence Planning has particular requirements around scientific context, source traceability, structured outputs and collaboration. Organisations should therefore look beyond speed and consider whether a tool can:

  • Work with evidence relevant to the task.

  • Support consistent, context-aware exploration.

  • Trace answers back to their sources.

  • Generate structured, referenced outputs.

  • Fit into existing review and delivery workflows.

  • Demonstrate appropriate testing and verification for its intended use cases.

General performance benchmarks alone do not establish that a tool will deliver reliable results in a specific Evidence Planning context. Explore Arysana’s approach to AI validation through our GenAI-VERIFY framework, which includes testing Validation/Evaluation, Robustness, Integrity/Fairness, and Yield or actual Impact on research efficiency.i

Explore our research on AI trust for Evidence Planning use cases

Bringing these principles into practice with Maia and ATLAS

Bringing these principles into practice with Maia and ATLAS

Bringing these principles into practice with Maia and ATLAS

At Arysana, these considerations inform our approach and research on AI-enabled Evidence Planning methodsi,ii,iii,iv.

Maia, the AI assistant within ATLAS, is designed to support evidence exploration within the wider planning workflow. Its capabilities include consistent prompts aligned with Evidence Planning questions, access to a shared evidence library, traceable answers, structured outputs and exportable Word reports.

Teams can use Maia to explore existing evidence, investigate potential evidence gaps and generate referenced outputs to support further review and use.

The aim is to help evidence professionals spend less time assembling information and more time applying their expertise. As with any AI-generated content, appropriate review and human judgement remain important.

The real measure of AI is what teams can do next

The real measure of AI is what teams can do next

The real measure of AI is what teams can do next

AI has the potential to make evidence exploration faster and more accessible. But speed is only part of the opportunity.

The greater value comes when AI helps connect the right evidence to the right question, makes answers easier to verify, presents information in useful formats and supports the next step in the workflow.

A fast answer isn't always a useful answer. The right AI needs the right evidence, context, traceability and workflow.

Discover how Maia is designed around the Evidence Planning process with ATLAS. Get in touch with the Arysana team to learn more and explore our other blog posts related to Integrated Evidence Planning, AI-enabled approaches, moving earlier with Integrated TPPs and moving beyond ‘static’ GVDs.

References:

i Keyloun, K., Outteridge, G. J., Bishop, G., Sabir, A., Reinsch, T., & Yu, J. (2026). FAST & FURIOUS HEOR impact: The AI assistant playbook to build trust and resiliency in the fast-paced world of large language models (LLMs). Value in Health, 29(S6) [Poster]. ISPOR 2026, Philadelphia, PA, United States.

ii Keyloun, K., Reinsch, T., Outteridge, G. J., Sydun, I., Sabir, A., Shaheen, J., & Bishop, G. (2026). Goldilocks and the three retrieval approaches: Human-reviewed validation of large language model (LLM) embedding-driven retrieval for trustworthy evidence gap analysis and value dossier drafting. Value in Health, 29(12S) [Poster]. ISPOR Europe 2026, Vienna, Austria.

iii Keyloun, K. (Moderator), Byrom, B., Foley, C., & Amelio, J. (2026). The GenAI paradox for qualitative evidence summarization: Exploring real-world use cases and validation frameworks for understudied but impactful use cases [Workshop]. ISPOR 2026, Philadelphia, PA, United States.

iv Keyloun, K., Yu, J., & Reinsch, T. (2025). AI assistant meets human: Refining methods for research-tailored AI assistants to support global product strategy, decision making, and HEOR impact. Value in Health, 28(S2) [Poster]. ISPOR Europe 2025, Glasgow, Scotland.

Logo

A Biopharma-Specialist Software Innovator

Arysana develops digital solutions for biopharma evidence generation and dissemination workflows

Logo

A Biopharma-Specialist Software Innovator

Arysana develops digital solutions for biopharma evidence generation and dissemination workflows

Logo

A Biopharma-Specialist Software Innovator

Arysana develops digital solutions for biopharma evidence generation and dissemination workflows